Competitive Website Audits: How to Outrank Your Local Competitors
So, you’re wondering, ‘What exactly is a website audit, and how can it help you outrank your competition?
Think of it like a comprehensive assessment or a checkup for your website. It’s a process where we thoroughly analyse your site to identify issues that might be holding it back and pinpoint opportunities for improvement. We examine various aspects to make sure everything is running smoothly and effectively to help you reach your online goals.
Running an audit is crucial because it highlights where your website can be improved and helps you prioritise actions. This can lead to better search engine rankings, more website visitors, higher conversion rates, and generally a much better experience for anyone visiting your site. It will also help you to work out how you can outrank your competitors. In essence, it shows you what’s working and what’s not so you can fix it and help your business grow.
A typical website audit covers several key areas, including things like the technical setup of your site (like speed and mobile-friendliness), how individual pages are optimised (on-page SEO), external factors like backlinks (off-page SEO), the overall user experience and design, and the quality and relevance of your content.
That’s the quick rundown! If you want to dive deeper into exactly what each of these areas entails and how to actually perform an audit yourself, you’ll find a ton more detailed information throughout the rest of the article.
Outrank Your Competitors In Google Search
Let’s talk about getting your business website to perform at its peak and, crucially, how that helps you get ahead of the competition right here in South Africa. It’s not just about having a website anymore; it’s about having one that actively works for your business, bringing in customers and helping you stand out. This is where a good old website audit comes into play.
Think of it like taking your car in for a service. You know it’s running, but a mechanic gives it a thorough check to ensure everything is working optimally and to spot any potential problems before they cause a breakdown. A website audit does the same thing for your online presence. It’s a deep dive into your site to understand what’s working, what’s not, and most importantly, how you can improve.
Maybe your website isn’t doing what you hoped it would. Perhaps it’s stopped performing as well as it used to, or you just have that feeling that something’s off. Audits are the way to figure out exactly what the issues are. They can help you understand typical problems that might exist on your site that you weren’t even aware of. Ultimately, a website audit can show you the path forward to make your business grow.
Performing audits regularly is a good idea. Some suggest doing one at least twice a year, or even quarterly if you update your site frequently. These checks help you improve your SEO and conversion rates, increase traffic, spruce up the design, and positively impact user acquisition.
But how does this all connect to outranking your competitors? Well, by identifying and fixing the weaknesses in your own site, you automatically make it stronger. And by analysing what your top competitors are doing, you can find opportunities to do it better.
What’s Covered in a Website Audit?
A comprehensive website audit examines various facets of your online presence. It’s not just about how the site looks; it’s about how it functions, how discoverable it is, and how it engages visitors. The goal is to get the most out of your website.
Here are some key areas typically covered:
- Technical Issues: This is often the first and arguably most important part. It checks the foundational elements of your site to ensure everything is running smoothly. This includes verifying you have an SSL certificate for security, checking that your Content Management System (CMS) works correctly, ensuring security best practices are implemented, and confirming your site works across different browsers and devices.
It also looks at whether you’re using tools like Google Analytics for reporting, if plugins and software are up-to-date, and if your site is regularly backed up. Identifying and fixing technical problems is vital because they can seriously affect how your site functions and how search engines perceive it. - Web Design and User Experience (UX): Your website’s design is the first impression. It needs to be appealing and make visitors want to stay, not click away. A UX audit assesses if your site structure is easy to navigate (like headers, body, footers), if the design leads users to interactive elements like calls to action (CTAs), and if all design elements are consistent with your brand.
It also looks at practical things like page load speed, especially on pages with images, and whether images are compressed for faster loading. A good UX ensures visitors have a positive experience, making them more likely to stay and convert. If navigation is confusing or important contact information is hard to find (like a phone number not being sticky on mobile), visitors will leave. - On-Page SEO: This is where you have a lot of control and can make relatively quick changes. An on-page audit checks if every page has a keyword-optimized title tag and meta description, if your content is the right length and uses keywords effectively, and if the content is relevant and valuable to your audience.
It also ensures you have clear contact indicators like phone numbers and email addresses and important pages like a Privacy Policy. Checking your XML sitemap is also part of this to help search engines index your site correctly. Making sure your URL structures are readable and optimized is key too. These elements directly impact how well individual pages rank for specific keywords. - Backlink Profile: Backlinks are links from other websites to yours. They are like votes of confidence and are really important for ranking and building authority. An audit looks at the quantity and quality of links pointing to your site. Are they from reputable sites? Are they relevant to your business or industry?
It also checks for potentially harmful or spammy links that could hurt your rankings. Analysing anchor text (the clickable text of the link) is important too. Comparing your backlink profile to competitors helps you see where you stand and identify opportunities to gain more links. - Content Assessment: Content is what makes your website worth visiting. This audit checks for issues with meta tags, headings, and word count. It also helps you find duplicate content, which can confuse search engines.
By looking at which pages and content pieces are performing best (getting the most traffic or links), you can understand what resonates with your audience and identify ideas for new content. This includes doing a “content gap analysis” by seeing what keywords your competitors rank for that you don’t. Creating better content on those topics can help you outrank them and steal some of their organic traffic. - Website Performance: How quickly your website loads is crucial for both user experience and search engine rankings. People are impatient; if your site takes too long to load (more than a few seconds), they’ll leave and go to a competitor.
Performance audits look at metrics like page load speed, including Core Web Vitals, and check mobile usability. Tools like Google PageSpeed Insights can check individual pages, while other tools can give you bulk data.
Why Local SEO Audits are Essential in South Africa
For many South African businesses, especially those serving a local area, appearing in local search results is critical. When someone searches for a product or service “near me” (like “plumbers in Durbanville” or “restaurants in Sandton”), Google understands they are looking for businesses nearby.
Google ranks local businesses based on three main factors: relevance, distance, and prominence.
- Distance is about how close the searcher is to your business.
- Relevance is how well your business matches the search query, based on information online.
- Prominence is how well-known and trusted your business is, influenced by things like online reviews, backlinks, and mentions.
A Local SEO audit specifically focuses on these factors to see how visible and well you perform in these local searches. It looks at your website’s SEO but also “off-page SEO” elements like business directory listings and customer reviews.
Key components of a Local SEO audit include:
- Google Business Profile (GBP) Analysis: Your GBP is your listing on Google Maps and Google Search. It’s what often shows up in the “Local Pack” (the map with a few business listings below it). Having a complete and accurate GBP is considered a very important local ranking factor.
An audit checks if your information (address, phone, hours) is correct, if you’ve chosen the right business categories, and if you regularly update your profile with posts or photos. It also looks at how you manage reviews and respond to questions. Auditing competitor GBPs can show you what they’re doing well. - Website Optimization for Local Search: While a general audit covers on-page SEO, a local audit specifically checks if your website is optimized for local keywords. This means using relevant keywords that target your local area (like “HVAC repair Randburg” in one example).
It involves ensuring these keywords are used in titles, descriptions, headings, and content. For businesses serving a specific region, using the city or area name in strategic places is important. - Local Citations Analysis: Citations are mentions of your business name, address, and phone number (NAP) on other websites, especially online directories like Hello Peter, Brabys, and other local directories specific to South Africa.
Consistency of your NAP across all these listings is crucial. Google uses these citations to verify your business information. Inconsistent details can hurt Google’s confidence in your data and negatively impact your rankings. Auditing your citations helps you find and correct any discrepancies and build more listings. - Customer Review Management: Reviews, particularly Google Reviews, are very important for local search rankings and building trust. An audit assesses the quantity and quality of your reviews, whether they are recent, and your average star rating.
Responding to reviews, both positive and negative, is also key. Comparing your review profile to competitors shows you if you need to focus on getting more or better reviews. - Backlinks and Authority: As with a general audit, checking backlinks is vital. For local SEO, the relevance of the linking site is key – are they local websites, industry sites, or reputable directories? Mentions of your brand online, even without a direct link (implied links), can also help build prominence.
- Checking for Google Penalties: Sometimes a sudden drop in rankings can be due to a manual penalty from Google. An audit includes checking Google Search Console for any notifications about penalties and addressing the cause.
- Social Media Presence: While not as direct a ranking factor as GBP or citations, an active social media presence can contribute to your online prominence. An audit can check if your profiles are consistent and regularly updated.
Tools of the Trade
You don’t have to do all of this manually. There are many tools available, both free and paid, that can help automate parts of the audit process.
Some popular tools include Ahrefs, Semrush, Ubersuggest, Screaming Frog, Moz, and SE Ranking for broader SEO audits. For local SEO specifically, tools like BrightLocal and WhiteSpark are useful. Google offers essential free tools like Google Search Console (for technical issues, indexing, and keyword rankings), Google PageSpeed Insights (for website performance), and Google Keyword Planner (for keyword ideas).
Paid Tools
Many paid tools offer comprehensive site audits, check backlinks, help with keyword research, and, crucially, allow you to analyse your competitors. This competitor analysis is where you gain insights into their strategies and find opportunities to improve your own to outrank your competitors.
Here’s a simplified look at how different audit areas directly impact your ability to outperform competitors:
| Audit Area | What it Reveals | How it Helps You Outrank Competitors |
|---|---|---|
| Technical | Site speed, security, mobile usability, indexing. | Ensures your site is fast and accessible, giving users and search engines a better experience than slower/broken competitor sites. Improves crawlability and indexing. |
| Design/UX | Ease of navigation, clarity, visual appeal, CTAs. | Keeps visitors engaged and makes it easy for them to find information or take action, leading to higher conversions compared to frustrating competitor sites. |
| On-Page SEO | Keyword usage, content quality, titles, headings. | Optimises your pages for specific search terms, making them more relevant than competitors for those keywords. Attracts more clicks with compelling titles/descriptions. |
| Local SEO (GBP/Citations) | Accuracy of business info, online mentions. | Builds trust with Google and users by ensuring consistent, verifiable information across the web. Increases online prominence compared to competitors with incomplete listings. |
| Reviews | Customer satisfaction, reputation. | Builds social proof and trust. Higher ratings and more recent reviews influence both users and Google positively compared to competitors with poor or old reviews. |
| Backlinks/Authority | Website credibility and influence. | Improves your site’s authority in the eyes of search engines, allowing you to rank higher than competitors with weaker backlink profiles. |
| Content | Relevancy, depth, identifying gaps. | Provides valuable content that answers user questions better than competitors. Fills content gaps by targeting keywords competitors rank for, attracting their audience. |
Putting the Audit Findings to Work
Once you’ve completed the audit, you’ll likely have a list of issues and opportunities. These are often prioritised, with “important issues” flagged so you know where to start. Fixing these problems is how you translate the audit’s findings into improved performance and, ultimately, how you outrank your competitors.
Sometimes, fixing an issue is as simple as adding a meta description. Other times, it might involve technical adjustments or developing new content. For WordPress sites, tools like AIOSEO can make many technical SEO tasks simpler. Some changes, especially significant redesigns or technical overhauls, might require professional help.
The real power comes from the insights you gain into your competitors. Seeing which keywords they rank for, who links to them, or how they structure their site can give you a roadmap for your own strategy to outrank your competitors.
The Path Forward
Getting your website to perform optimally and outrank your competitors isn’t about finding some secret hack or silver bullet. It’s about mastering the basics and ensuring your online presence is solid, user-friendly, and visible to search engines.
Website audits, including a specific focus on local SEO elements for businesses serving a defined geDiscover how a website audit can help you identify critical issues, boost performance, and effectively outrDiscover how a website audit can help you identify critical issues, boost performance, and effectively outrank your competitorsank your competitorsographic area in South Africa, are the structured way to do this. They provide a clear list of priorities and action steps based on data.
By regularly checking your technical health, user experience, on-page optimisation, local signals, backlinks, and content, you ensure your site is always in the best shape to attract and convert customers.
Don’t let potential issues hold your business back. Regular website audits are an investment in your online visibility and a critical strategy to help you outrank your competitors in the competitive South African digital landscape.
Frequently Asked Questions
What exactly is a website audit?
Think of a website audit as a comprehensive assessment or a thorough analysis of your website’s performance. It’s like getting a checkup for your website to make sure everything is in good shape.
The process involves examining various aspects of your site to identify any issues that might be stopping it from performing well. It also helps uncover opportunities for improvement. A general website audit can cover everything from technical aspects and user experience to on-page and off-page SEO factors, design, and content issues.
Why is a website audit crucial for businesses aiming to outrank their competitors?
Running an audit is absolutely crucial because it helps you identify areas for improvement and allows you to prioritise the actions needed to boost your online presence. It’s about giving your website a deep clean so it looks its best for visitors. A good audit can lead to some great benefits, like better search engine rankings, more website traffic, higher conversion rates, and an overall better user experience for people visiting your site. It effectively shows you what’s working and what’s not so you can fix things and help your business grow. In a constantly changing online world, regular audits ensure your site stays efficient, effective, and aligned with your business goals .
What key areas are typically covered in a website audit?
A comprehensive website audit looks at several key areas to give you a full picture of your site’s performance:
Technical SEO: This involves checking things like your site’s speed, whether it works well on mobile devices, if you have a secure SSL certificate, if Google can easily index and crawl your site, and the overall site structure. It also looks at things like CMS functionality, security best practices, browser compatibility, Google Analytics setup, plugin updates, and backups. Technical issues are often checked first because they can affect everything else.
On-Page SEO: This focuses on optimising individual pages. It includes checking meta titles and descriptions, headings, the quality and relevance of your content, how keywords are used, and your URL structures. It also includes ensuring content is the right length, checking for relevancy indicators like phone numbers or email addresses, and having essential pages like a Privacy Policy.
Off-Page SEO: This looks at external factors that influence your site, such as your backlink profile (links from other websites), brand mentions, local citations (business directory listings), and online reviews.
User Experience (UX): This assesses how easy and pleasant your website is for visitors to use. It covers the design, navigation, how clear your calls to action are, and the overall ease of use. It involves looking at the aesthetics, page structure, navigation, interactive elements, image optimisation, and consistency in design elements.
Content: This is about reviewing the quality, relevance, and amount of content on your site. It involves identifying content gaps, removing poor-quality or duplicate content, and ensuring your content meets Google’s guidelines.
Design: This focuses on the visual aspects, consistency, and overall look and feel of the website.
How does a local SEO audit help small businesses outrank larger competitors in regional searches?
A local SEO audit is a specific type of website audit that focuses on factors particularly important for businesses serving a specific geographic area. While a general audit looks at broad website performance and SEO, a local SEO audit specifically examines elements that affect how well a business ranks in local search results, like the Google Local Pack or Google Maps. The main difference is the focus on local ranking factors. Key elements of a local SEO audit include analysing your Google Business Profile, managing customer reviews, and checking local citations or business directory listings. It helps local businesses understand where they can improve to be more visible to nearby customers .
How often should I conduct a website audit to maintain a competitive edge and consistently outrank rivals?
The frequency really depends on things like how big and complex your website is, how often you add new content, and how the digital world changes. As a general rule, it’s a good idea to do a comprehensive website audit at least once or twice a year. However, if you update your site frequently, publish content often, or if there have been big changes like new search algorithm updates, you might benefit from doing a quarterly audit to keep on top of things .
What tools can I use to perform a website audit?
There are quite a few tools available to help with website audits, ranging from free to paid options. Some popular ones include:
Google Search Console and Google Analytics: Free tools from Google providing insights into your site’s performance, traffic, and user behaviour.
Ahrefs and Semrush: Powerful paid platforms that offer extensive features for site audits, keyword research, competitor analysis, and backlink checks. Semrush also has specific tools for local SEO like listing management and rank tracking. Ahrefs has a free version (Webmaster Tools) but with limitations compared to the paid one.
BrightLocal: A specialised tool focusing on local SEO audits, including citations, reviews, and local rankings.
AIOSEO (All in One SEO): A WordPress plugin that includes an SEO Analyzer feature for site audits, including a homepage audit checklist. They also offer a free SEO Analyzer tool online for any URL.
Ubersuggest, Screaming Frog, SE ranking: Other tools mentioned for performing audits.
Tools like Smartlook, Crazyegg, or Hotjar can help with the User Experience (UX) assessment using heat maps.
Google’s PageSpeed Insights can check the performance of a single page. The best tool for you will often depend on the scope of your audit and your budget.
What common issues can hinder my ability to outrank competitors, and how can an audit address them?
Audits often reveal typical problems that can harm performance:
Technical Issues: Things like broken links, pages that Google can’t crawl, slow page loading times, problems with mobile usability, and incorrect or missing SSL certificates.
On-Page Problems: This includes missing or poorly written meta titles and descriptions, weak or irrelevant content, not using keywords effectively, and confusing or unfriendly URL structures.
Off-Page Problems: Such as a weak backlink profile with too few or low-quality links, business information (NAP: Name, Address, Phone Number) that is inconsistent or wrong across online listings, or not having enough online reviews.
User Experience Issues: Like difficult navigation, unclear calls to action, websites that don’t work well on mobile, or inconsistent/unappealing design.
Content Issues: Finding gaps where content is missing on important topics, or having duplicate content.
Local SEO Specific Issues: This includes incomplete or inaccurate Google Business Profiles, not updating your profile regularly, or not responding to customer reviews. Finding and fixing these issues is key to improving your website’s performance and visibility .
How can hiring a professional website auditor help me effectively outrank my competition?
While you can do some basic checks yourself, getting a professional audit offers several advantages: Professionals have a lot of experience and a deep understanding of SEO and website performance. They can use more advanced tools and methods for a very thorough analysis. Professionals are good at spotting less obvious problems. They can provide actionable recommendations that are specifically tailored to your business goals. This can save you time and effort, ensure important issues are fixed effectively, and give you a clear plan to improve your online presence and help your business grow. They truly understand what makes a website function well .
